Harden's survey result
For 25 years we've been curating reviews of the UK's most notable restaurant. This year diners have submitted over 60,000 reviews to create the most authoritative restaurant guide in the UK.
“A nice balance between pub and restaurant” – this well-known Islingtonian knocks out an “interesting seasonal menu”, although “service can be patchy”. “The wine list is a real delight, with a huge range of bottles priced to invite exploration”.
“Excellent pub food” (“love the pies!”) lives up to the high reputation of this Islington gastro-boozer, although the “interesting, regularly changing menu” is “sometimes let down by surly service”. Top tip for the summer: “there’s a fabulous sun-trap garden at the back”.
“Sociable” Islington gastropub, which remains a bit hit locally; service is “inconsistent” however, and the food can turn out “mediocre” – “go for the excellent, knowledgeably-selected wines”.
This “very Farrow & Ball” gastropub is something of an Islington linchpin, with a “great atmosphere”, and food that’s of “a continually high standard and variety”; it can get “too busy and noisy” at peak times.
The Drapers Arms N1
In a quiet part of Islington, an elegant Georgian boozer recently relaunched with gastro-ambitions; the straightforward English food is the weakest part of a 'package' which, overall, offers good value.
It's very difficult not to like this handsome pub, which is both spiritually and physically well removed from the tawdry delights of Islington's Upper Street. It's already had one spell of success as a gastro-destination, then it went downhill, and ultimately into liquidation.
Now it's been relaunched by a likeable young team, one of whom is the offspring of the lady invariably known as the doyenne of the London restaurant critical world. Expect many reviews.
The new incarnation is not so very different from the old, in that the building is - almost self-consciously - allowed to speak for itself. There is almost no decoration to distract from the Georgian sobriety. The effect can be uplifting, particularly in the bright upstairs room, flooded with light from five great sash windows. There is also an attractive garden.
The food is rather like the décor: entirely unornamented. This is an admirable aim, but it needs to be carried off with panache if the results are to be at all notable. We're not frankly sure they've quite managed it.
This was a solo visit, but even one person can sample a fair proportion of the short menu. The dishes we had were all fine, but none made any real impression. Perhaps unfortunately, the best effort - tasty brown crab on crusty toast - came first. Thereafter, neither an omelette (a crucial test for any kitchen) nor a bavarois hit any sort of heights.
Prices, however, are not demanding, and the service tries hard. If you don't seek the place out with unduly high culinary expectations, we suspect that you may find a visit here quite a pleasure.
44 Barnsbury Street, London, N1 1ER
|Number of Diners:|
Mon - Fri noon - 3 pm, 6 pm - 10.30 pm; Sat noon - 4 pm, 7 pm - 10.30 pm; Sun noon - 8.30 pm
Last orders: 10.30 pm