Harden's survey result
For 25 years we've been curating reviews of the UK's most notable restaurant. This year diners have submitted over 60,000 reviews to create the most authoritative restaurant guide in the UK.
“Maybe a victim of its own success?” – Jason Atherton’s first solo venture in Mayfair remains one of London’s most popular destinations, but “seems to have lost its way a bit”. To fans, the “dreamy” and “creative cuisine” is a “perfect indulgence”; and even if the “cool” decor has a challenging acoustic (“for Social, read noisy”) they applaud a “refreshingly relaxed approach to fine dining” that’s “not too fussy and formal”. Doubters, however, have had meals here that “lack any wow-factor” and choke on prices that are now “the wrong side of excruciating”.
Eeeessh! – turns out Jason Atherton isn’t superhuman after all, as falling ratings at his original solo venture give the first hints of growing pains amidst his burgeoning (but hitherto seemingly bulletproof) empire. This, the original Social, still has legions of fans who laud its “utterly inventive” cuisine and “buzzy” (if “downright noisy”) vibe, but its performance has seemed more “generic” and “passionless” of late, with gripes over “unmemorable” meals at high prices, and “conveyor-belt” service.
A “very slick” Mayfair hangout, where Jason Atherton’s “flavour-popping” menu includes many “stunning” dishes; its “light and bright” interior and “vibrant” style, however, ensures that it’s “not the place for a romantic supper!”
Jason Atherton’s “genuinely exciting” cuisine – “fresh in every sense” – again inspires adulation for his Mayfair two-year-old (where the “amazing dessert bar” is a “highlight”); the décor is “a bit bland”, though, and some reporters can find dishes “over-engineered”.
Pollen Street Social Restaurant Diner Reviews
"This is a very special restaurant-faultless"
"Impressive cuisine, with some very novel dishes, beautifully presented, but eye wateringly expensive, and deafening accoustics! Great for a group, but not the place for a quiet romantic evening!"
"Very nice touches with amuse bouches etc but the prices are eye watering."
Pollen Street Social W1
The first solo London operation from Jason Atherton, the man who made 'Maze' for Gordon Ramsay; the formula - innovative, without it any way being startling - is nicely pitched, and already attracting a strong Mayfair following.
The unassuming Jason Atherton is one of the most able chefs to have made his name as part of the Gordon Ramsay stable - Maze was for many years one of the few undoubted stars in a constellation too often sustained by hype, and by Michelin. (Where one stopped, and the other began, we wouldn't like to say.)
Leaving aside a 'name' restaurant launched last year in Shanghai (obviously), this is the first restaurant Atherton has established on his own, (and, it appears, largely with his own money). So it was rather a surprise when early-days reviews on his new Mayfair premises were rather mixed. With one exception we'll come to later, however, our experience - a few weeks after opening - was of consistent high standards.
Initial impressions of the space are comforting: quite no-nonsense, by local standards, handsome enough, but without any fancy finishes. The menu style turns out to be pretty much in keeping - this is not a restaurant where you get bombarded with amuses and inter-courses. Our test meal: a lunch for two, offering the opportunity to check out most of the three-options-a-course set lunch menu.
The bread, seemingly home-made, made a very good initial impression, and the starters impressed with their precise timing - asparagus, for example - and their clarity and freshness. Both first courses - particularly one presented on a black plate, and featuring chilled beetroot mousse, as well as mackerel and horseradish cream - were a picture.
The cod main course - a smallish piece, presented in a soup-type dish under a white froth (or, more technically, a peas and cockle emulsion) - appeared to the eye as simply a white swirl. Of the taste, however, the recipient made no complaint. The other main course, a lamb rump, presented relatively conventionally, was difficult to fault.
Given that this is a restaurant which boasts an - innovative - dessert bar, it was curious that it was only at the final stage that the meal showed any sign of faltering. Both of us were enticed by the prospect of the strawberry and tomato gazpacho. By common consent, however, the black olive sorbet that came with it only detracted from the whole.
By the time of coffee and - first freebie of the meal! - chocolates, however, the impressive form which otherwise characterised our visit was comfortably re-established.
8-10 Pollen St, London, W1S 1NQ
|Number of Diners:|
lunch noon - 2.30 pm. dinner 6 pm - 10.30 pm
Last orders: 10.30 pm