Sign up for NewsletterJoin Hardens Community | Member Log-in

Restaurant News & Views

25th April 2012

Weekend Press Roundup

SUNDAY

Smoak M1

Lisa Markwell, The Independent on Sunday (Rating: 6/10)

With a “menu big in both dimension and range” this new Manchester steakhouse (in the former brasserie space in Malmaison), leaves Lisa “defeated by the portion sizes”; the steak is “superb”, but most other dishes are disappointing – “decent” at best – and “the atmosphere is going to take some serious fanning to get going”.

Magdalen Arms OX4

AA Gill, The Sunday Times (Rating: Food 4/5, Atmosphere 3/5)

“More pubby than gastro”, this Oxford restaurant (sister to London's Anchor and Hope and Great Queen Street) “has a lot to smile about” - it's “what inn food should be, selective and generous”

Kitchen Joël Antunès W1

Jay Rayner, The Observer

“Here the context is all wrong” – “it's very nice, but” you'll end up paying big for “gutsy, rustic” dishes which feature better in a “tablecloth-free bistro” than this Mayfair location (Antunes moved here from his first location at Park Plaza Westminster Bridge); Jay “desperately” wants to like it but, it's hard to ignore the “sour taste” left behind when the bill arrives.

SATURDAY

Pitt Cue Co W1

Matthew Norman, The Telegraph (Rating: 9/10)

Not the place to linger, this “tiny, cramped basement room” in Soho serves “droolsomely delicious” “generous” portions of American barbecue; dining here may be a bit ”stripped to the bone”, but they “feed you well at very decent prices”.

Jimmy's Farm IP9

John Lanchester, The Guardian

From “celebrity farmer” Jimmy Doherty (chum of Jamie Oliver) this new restaurant, in a converted barn on his Suffolk farm, is “comfortable, but not too gussied up” and the food is “good“ but “not amazing”.

Adam Simmonds SL7

John Walsh, The Independent (Rating: Food 4/5, Ambience 3/5, Service 4/5)

“The food mostly matches the monochrome décor” of this Marlow hotel and restaurant, with chef Adam Simmonds at the helm, “but from start to finish is full of vivid flavours”; the dining experience may be “a vestal shrine to minimalism and frictionless efficiency” with service that “never strayed into friendliness” but, overall, “the food's delicious”.

Comments (0)

To post a comment you must be registered and signed in.

Register | Sign in
Advanced Search
Find restaurants to match the following criteria
location (only one!)
key features

quality
other features (London searches only)
Map Search
Find venues by location using UK or London Maps
close button