Harden's survey result
For 25 years we've been curating reviews of the UK's most notable restaurant. This year diners have submitted over 60,000 reviews to create the most authoritative restaurant guide in the UK.
“To ‘seal the deal’ with a date”, this “old world”, “rickety” Soho “haunt” – “all flickering candlelight and rustic Bohemian style” – has few equals. The “ever-changing”, “simple”, “seasonal” fare is “honest” and “always reliable”, but “the wine makes a meal exceptional” – “an amazing choice” from arguably “the best-value list in London”.
“For the perfect first date”, this “magical” (if “cramped”), candle-lit Soho townhouse is second to none – a “shabby-chic treasure” that’s “barely changed in three decades” (although actually, behind the scenes, they put in a big new kitchen this year). The “simple, daily changing fare” is unfailingly good value, but the star turn is the “incredible wines at stunning prices”.
“Unique” and “utterly charming”, this ancient candlelit Soho townhouse remains one of London’s most prodigiously popular bolt-holes; “squashed” it may be, and the “extraordinary” wine may outshine the cuisine (“reasonably priced” as it is)… but “if you only have eyes for your date, this is the place!”
“The quintessence of shabby chic” – this “quirky”, “candlelit” Soho phenomenon is “the kind of place you find in Paris not London”, and “incredibly romantic”; its “simple”, “refreshingly honest” cooking is “good (but not knock-out)”, but the “eclectic, encyclopaedic list of wines is truly wonderful”; “sit upstairs if you can”.
Andrew Edmunds Restaurant Diner Reviews
"Went for dinner with my wife, whereas I had previously only eaten there at lunchtime. It was very busy which possibly accounted for a slight reduction in the standard of food and service."
"This restaurant is a unique experience. I can understand why it is so busy when the food is good quality and prepared with such skill. The surroundings in this small Georgian house are very cosy and indeed there is so little room between tables the waiting staff often struggle to keep cutlery on the plates as they clear the tables. However it all makes for a surprisingly enjoyable experience and one cannot fault the price value balance."
"Have wanted to visit this restaurant for a long time after reading such glowing reviews. Really didn't know what to expect and the venue certainly has character in bucketloads. Service was friendly though a little erratic on the night we went - rather too many pieces of cutlery flying across the floor. Really not surprising given how close the tables are together. However clearly the food is prepared with passion and care. All the dishes were perfectly cooked and very tasty. Certainly I can understand the reason it is so busy when you consider the prices and I will be returning."
"Slightly shambolic..too many dishes not available quite early in the evening."
"Little to add to my review of last August, other than it is looking a little shabby."
"Nice restaurant in Soho for a lower price point. very good value for money."
"Still the best place to go for a special treat. Flawless service, excellent food and selection of wine, although the latter is getting pricier."
"Like a private getaway in the heart of Soho, Andrew Edmunds never disappoints. My wife and I have been loyal customers here for 12 years and it is always excellent. The wine list is phenomenal on its own."
46 Lexington Street, London, W1F 0LP
Mon Fri noon - 3.30 pm, 5.30 pm - 10.45pm Sat 12.30 pm - 3.30 pm, 5.30 pm - 10.45 pm; Sun 1 pm - 4 pm, 6 pm - 10.30 pm
Last orders: 10.45 pm, Sun 10.30 pm